metricon homes liquidation

Moving the industry to cost plus would be a good start, but that comes with its own headaches, like ensuring the contractor isnt running two sets of books. Our subbies have been paid and we have not just pulled the rug out from under people.. Take about $150 off the rates for a barebone barely livable house. 5. 11. "Metricon was founded by Mario Biasin and George Kline in 1976. Even as the company was scrambling to secure additional funds, acting CEO Peter Langfelder, appointed after the sudden death earlier this month of Metricons founder and CEO Mario Biasin, denied the company had solvency issues and insisted the business remains viable. They almost got away with it the first time around. However building period hasnt started yet, and building approval is pending with council. Irwin says he had never seen the construction industry in this level of crisis in his 30 years in the sector, with the exponential rise in material costs seeing businesses like Next, Condev, Probuild and Privium all fold in the last six months. Our aim is to limit the financial damage before it happens with our members only forum, an early warning system for the benefit of all our members. He is also Chief Economist and co-founder of MacroBusiness. Now a special mention to the Minister for Public Works Mick De Brenni and his mates Master Builders Association for delaying once again Project Trust Accounts, the only real chance of saving subbies millions. In a bid to head off home buyers reluctance to risk laying down large deposits, Civic Screens Chief Executive Stefan Styles told the media: We dont believe the company is in trouble. Even so, Styles warned: The problem is that customers will become nervous and it will become a self-fulfilling prophecy.. The first report to creditors by the Liquidator Worrells says all staff will be paid in full and good luck to them. Watch David Norths remarks commemorating 25 years of the World Socialist Web Site and donate today. Being solvent is the ability to pay debts when they fall due. Pivotal Homes has been placed into liquidation with 103 . With any builder and assuming standard site costs, you are looking at at least $1200 per sqm for 1 storey, and $1600 per sqm for 2 storey for a livable house. This company was a residential construction company building homes up and down the East Coast of Australia. It is this long standing goal combined with an unwavering commitment to quality and excellence in design and service that has seen Metricon become Australia's leading and most trusted new home builder. This will demonstrate that they cannot leave matters in the hands of the unions, which are tied by a thousand threads to the corporations and the capitalist state, and serve as an industrial police force of management. May 27, 2022 One of Queensland's biggest home builders has gone into liquidation, while the NSW government is reportedly scrambling to build a bailout package for the country's largest building company as pressures mount in the construction industry. Its not just about the builders who go broke, businesses all over Australia Liquidate every day for a variety of reasons. May 16, 2022. Its a pretty simple process, build up a huge debt, cancel you license so the QBCC cant help subbies and liquidate the company after transferring the assets for no commercial value into the phoenix. Metricon proudly builds new homes across Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland and South Australia. One industry . Metricon's future remains uncertain while families await construction on homes. I remember Consolidated Constructions, here in WA who went bust in 2004. On JamesEdition you can find luxury homes in Milan of any . Metricon, Australia's largest home builder, struck a deal on Friday for an emergency doubling of its working capital credit facility, in an effort to stave off bankruptcy amid a mounting crisis. Watch Revenue scramble as all the SMBs hit the wall, and suppliers and vendors fold. They were breaking the law by taking deposits but not paying for their customers home owners warranty insurance or the interstate equivalent so many of their hundreds of customers were left with sweet FA. It is an unfortunate set of circumstances that is impacting the industry across Australia.. All of their assets are in family trusts/relatives names. There are also more homes approved and waiting commencement than in any previous cycle, [stated HIA Chief Economist]. Liquidation Hall of Shame - Let the Countdown Begin. Metricon have been operating since 1976. Who founded the business, and do they still influence the thinking and culture of the company? Straight out of the 2008 European playbook.but but but it would never happen here! Metricon | 44,708 followers on LinkedIn. Builders.. always smartest blokes in the room, always broke, but always seem to to have a nice house and all the toys. Housing icon Metricon is helping to make the Aussie dream a reality, breaking down the barriers between you and your future forever-home. Construction giant Metricon is also reportedly on the verge of collapse following last weeks sudden death of founder and CEO Mario Biasin. How much of this is due to end-of-financial-year phoenixing? Below is Helix Legals summary of the PBA changes lobbied by MBA and caved in on by the minister for public works. This is with standard inclusions and no upgrades, this house includes: 3 bedrooms. 3. A Commercial Construction company, Probuild undercut its way to the top of the pile and had the excellent excuse that Covid bought them undone. Isnt it amazing what a little inflation can do to change things. It looks genius until it fails, then it looks stupid. The accessory solves a daily problem encountered by owners of Frank Greens 34oz/1 litre ceramic drink bottles but the story of its design is a quirky one that involves TikTok, Bunnings and painted PVC pipes. Hi, This is my first post. I have to ask why a government minister acquiesces so often and so willingly to a bunch like the MBA after making unkept promises to the industry. Metricon confirmed Mario Biasin died unexpectedly on Monday, after suffering mental health issues. This impressive 64 square home is the embodiment of contemporary farmhouse living, emanating tranquillity. Oh, and let's not forget to give BA Murphy a 20 million dollar mention. Please tick to verify that you are not a robot. Disgruntled with Metricon and Pre-Site Manager process Disgruntled with Metricon and Pre-Site Manager process. In a press conference the head sherang said it had nothing to do with undercutting the opposition, going in with the cheapest quotes to win jobs and not taking into account price increase and labour shortage. According to the Housing Industry Association, Metricon completed 6,052 dwellings last year and 4,354 in 2020. The Metricon Homes price list is something you'll find at many display villages across the country, from Sydney, Brisbane, Melbourne, Gold Coast and even Geelong. As per above, smartest blokes in the room . supported browser to get the most Risk is transferred, through contract, to those least likely to be able to mitigate it usually smaller scale subbies. If you're not a subbie or a trusted supplier, you are not welcome. The devastated boss of collapsed Gold Coast homebuilder Pivotal Homes has blamed a blowout in building costs for the companys failure, warning that fixed-price building contracts are putting undue risk on contractors in the current perfect storm for the industry. Imagine labour has pricing power. While politicians and business leaders have held crisis meetings behind closed doors to work out a plan for the future of major home builder Metricon, Aussie families are now uncertain of what's to come. The announcement came at the end of a week in which the company held talks with the NSW government about possible financial support. Why are construction workers being idled and resources laid to waste when there exists a desperate need for the construction of vital social infrastructure, such as schools and hospitals, as well as high-quality public housing to deal with growing homelessness and the lack of affordable accommodation? You see it now and again when a builder rorts home owners and that might only be because it involves the QBCC paying out on their Home Warranty Insurance. Buckleys. And this is good news because it reduces the value of Capital in the equation and thereby reduces speculation. Without the basic information, you are flying a 747 with your eyes closed. Yes, developers do it to builders too! The Clara 15 is likely the base Metricon Home with a price between $150,000 and $200,000. We understand the pressure on builders on the eastern seaboard due to increases in costs, and the impacts this is having on the construction industry and residential clients, Pallas said after the meeting on May 19. Metricon also announced that its banking partner, Commonwealth Bank, had approved a 100% increase in the companys existing working capital facility. Metricon isn't the only builder feeling the pinch. Condev - at least the directors faced the media and paid their employees although that is not helping subbies get paid. This has been principally driven by not only COVID, but the shortage of supply of trades and labour.. Its projects in Queensland alone are worth more than $400 million, according to Queensland Building and Construction Commission records. Yep the better quality builders are all working on cost plus now. 03 9285 . Its been a perfect storm for the industry and the main drivers (of the liquidation) were the realisation by Michael of potential insolvency due to the rapid increase in pricing, particularly that associated with local trades, says Cronin, who also acted on behalf of Condev. Metricon's chief executive . You all deserve nothing but scorn for your spineless efforts in delaying project trust accounts yet again. "Today it was announced that Queenslands building industry is being given more time to prepare for the further expansion of the trust account framework which provides additional security of payment to smaller industry players.. As speculation grew last week over Metricons possible demise, Pivotal Homes, one of Queenslands largest home builders, went into liquidation. All made possible because we allowed ourselves to do this, we simply demanded that our labour to be properly priced. The devastated boss of collapsed Gold Coast homebuilder Pivotal Homes has blamed a blowout in building costs for the company's failure, warning that fixed-price building contracts are putting undue risk on contractors in the current 'perfect storm' for the industry. As many builders are small enterprises, its not too surprising that theyre trading insolvent as they likely manage their cashflows very tightly, and if the company is forced into liquidation, the builder will have to liquidate personal assets to meet company payments. Reviews about Metricon seem to differ between the cities. You'll also receive messages on behalf of our partners. Named: Multimillion-dollar collapses among Qld's 970 business failures. BA Murphy - read above but a relative baby when compared to the giants below. Sunshine Coast builder Pivotal Homes became the latest in a string of companies to call in the liquidators late on Thursday with managing director Michael Irwin blaming rising labour and construction costs for the downfall. I have been told by our lawyer to delete the commentary I had next to each builder so I will take his advice but suffice to say, I have substantial evidence that this is a fair assessment of just how bad they were. In any Western democracy it is a basic expectation that if someone breaks into your house, hijacks your car or steals money that belongs to you, the Police will be called to investigate and bring the perpetrators to justice. Prior to securing the additional loan from the Commonwealth Bank of Australia, Metricon met with the New South Wales (NSW), Victorian and federal governments to discuss the possibility of a bailout package, rumored at $100 million or more. The Prime Contractor may subbie out most of the works to another contractor, who then breaks it up further to smaller contractors. This is a logical extension of the role played by the unions for decades, enforcing the destruction of working conditions and the massive increase of casual, labour-hire and sham contracting arrangements across the construction industry. It can be difficult to prove when companies are right on the edge. In total, Metricon had 6052 homes under construction across the nation in 2020-21. With Privium, Probuild and now Condev going down in recent months, it's time for an update but the size of the disaster doesn't necessarily guarantee any of them the winners gong. Hence, home builders are experiencing a profitless boom, losing money despite being busier than ever. In addition to material costs, labour shortages are placing massive strain on the construction industry, with both the NSW and Victorian state governments now in conversation with the Albanese government to fast-track migrant worker visas. But for many in the residential construction . It has hired consultancy Sayers Group and was working on refinancing options before Biasin died. Probuild, a much loved pet of ARITA's for what it puts back into their members pockets (liquidators). Cronin concedes creditors could still be owed more than $2 million, although this is still subject to investigation by liquidators Chris Cook and James Robba, of Worrells. Only in this way can production be reorganised to serve social need, rather than the profit interests of the wealthy elite. The collapse of Pivotal Homes adds to heightened awareness of the crisis facing the construction industry. Gold Coast-based builder Pivotal Homes has collapsed. May 20, 2022 - 10:20AM Metricon founder Mario Biasin shared telling insights into the challenges facing the industry two years before his shock death this week. We often find ourselves filling every waking moment with activity, thinking that this is the only way to get ahead. Russ Stephens, co-founder of the Association of Professional Builders, told The Australian that the fact that Pivotal Homes and Solido had promised to pay all subcontractors in full showed that they had decided to fall on their sword in a calculated judgment that the companies couldnt continue viably in the current market. Acting CEO Peter Langfelder said industry and media speculation following the sudden and unexpected death of company founder Mario Biasin is Apparently there's many people taking Metricon to court over ** building practices. Builders use their sub-contractors trade supply accounts to build homes, many having to run lines of credit because 30,60 or even 90 terms are common. Download catalogue Designer Contemporary homes with light-filled rooms that are a joy to live in. Privum - Terrible effort by directors and money went flying everywhere except to creditors. The possible collapse of Metricon threatens the jobs of about 2,500 directly employed workers, primarily in eastern Australia, where it currently has around 4,000 homes under construction. Its about the participation of the banks, pre insolvency advisors and builder appointed Liquidators to fraudulently defeat creditors. I have to say as a group and a so called peak body, you do not act in the best interests of the industry. But is this really the case? However, Cronin says the company has gone into liquidation with cash in the bank. Other home building companies that went belly up over the last six months include two Tasmanian-based firms, Hotondo Homes, in February, and Inside Out Construction, in November. 2023 All Rights Reserved. Some of the individual stories we have been told by subbies would curl the hairs in your nose and make you vomit a little in your mouth. As part of a. Then HIH collapsed, and the government have to provide the insurance again, but they limited the liability by excluding high rise from the scheme. Metropolitan Melbourne and surrounding suburbs, Ballarat, Bendigo, Bairnsdale, Geelong, Gippsland, Shepparton, Warnambool and surrounding areas, Start your dream home journey with Metricon today, View this website for more information about supported browsers. Traditionally the risk had been with the homebuyer who could get ripped off by a builder. Metricon's owners have injected $30 million into the troubled company and the Commonwealth Bank has doubled its working capital facility in an effort to keep the country's largest home builder. Poor consumer protection for new home buyers has allowed builders who wish to do so (read greedy) to operate with Ponzi economics that encourage signing up more and more Metricon Homes Pty Ltd. 501 Blackburn Road, Mt Waverley VIC 3149. Russ Stephens, co-founder of the Association of Professional Builders, believes the recent collapses are merely the tip of the iceberg and estimates that half of Australian building companies are currently trading insolvent, meaning they cannot pay their bills. He came to this decision early. The company currently has 4,000 houses under construction. Recently we have seen multiple major residential construction companies go into liquidation, including Probuild, Condev, ABG Group, and Privium, alongside several smaller players like Hotondo Homes Hobart, Home Innovation Builders and Next. My biggest risk is my health, which Im insured against. The working class must have a political voice, which the Australian ruling class is seeking to stifle with this legislation. However building period hasnt started yet, and building approval is pending with council. Join the SEP campaign against anti-democratic electoral laws! With this elevated volume of homes in the pipeline, the number of homes under construction will remain at this high level until at least June 2023. That liquidation tips the builder into liquidation, at times through no fault of his own. NSW Contractor's Licence: 174699C (Metro/Southern), NSW Contractors Licence: 36654C (Northern), SA Builder's Licence: BLD231776, QLD - QBCC licence: 40992, VIC Builder's Licence: CDB-U 52967. In March, Queensland-based Condev Construction, which specialised in multi-unit residential constructions, retail and commercial premises, industrial units and warehouses, went into liquidation. Metricon Homes ranked as Australia's largest builder in 2021 for the sixth year in a row. He says Irwin understandably describes the industry as broken and that he wants to shine a light on the emerging problem. The question is, in the current conditions, is the risk being carried appropriately by the builder?. Metricon Homes It's not often that luxury living and home-building go hand-in-hand, but the tide is turning. In an attempt to shore up consumer and lender confidence in the failing firm, Metricon shareholders have also provided a $30 million injection of cash into the company. I recall margins on some of our jobs, were 2-3%, so inflation on Materials, Labour & Plant could easily put that into negative figures. Work alongside development specialists to get the most out of your land. A major Australian home builder, Melbourne's Metricon, is taking four months to construct an ordinary 200 square metre, one-storey home that would usually require three months. Click for more information. Russ Stephens, co-founder of the Association of Professional Builders, believes the recent collapses are merely the "tip of the iceberg" and estimates that half of Australian building . On the other hand, there is a school of thought that they are all as bad as each other but as in all walks of life, there is good and bad and circumstances can have an effect on a builder surviving. Agreed (somewhat) but my point is that without uncertainty in prices for materials and/or labour it is Capital and capital availability which represents the greatest project risk. Please complete the form below and click on SIGN UP to receive daily e-newsletters from. Legislators have since focused on rewriting contracts to ensure they are watertight with a fixed price that wouldnt allow a builder to hold a customer to ransom. Liquidators should always be appointed by creditors to ensure a thorough investigation takes place. Speculation mounted over the fate of Metricon, its 2,500 staff and 4,000 homes under construction Australia-wide following the death of founder and CEO Mario Biasin, but in the aftermath acting CEO Peter Langfelder claimed all contracts were profitable and . BA Murphy also had 50 unfinished building projects across Australia, including 21 in Queensland, 18 in Victoria and about 11 in New South Wales. Speccies galore for sale on the sunny coast, and usually sold before completed, some of these guys have been skinning the cat last few years. Often they sue you so they don't have to pay you. This information helps us show you the home designs, display centres, and packages that are most relevant to you. Imagine working your ring off only to end up worse off? All figures below are approximate because no one will ever know the collateral damage they cause. As always, there will be people who disagree with the final tally but the judges have spoken and please, by all means, submit your own list in the comments section below and keep it clean. The rumours escalated after the unexpected death of Metricon founder and CEO Mario Biasin earlier this month, although acting CEO Peter Langfelder denies the company is in dire straits and that it is business as usual for the group. Chris Cook and James Robba of Worrells were appointed liquidators of Pivotal Homes, which has built more than 1500 homes in its 15 years of operation. Metricon customers whose dream homes became nightmares Tawa Razaghi Domain / Sydney Morning Herald, https://www.smh.com.au/property/news/sleepless-nights-the-metricon-customers-whose-dream-homes-became-nightmares-20220523-p5ann1.html, Australias construction industry facing huge challenges as companies go under News com au, https://www.news.com.au/finance/business/australias-construction-industry-facing-huge-challenges-as-companies-go-under/news-story/fff7c3f77ae7abfd48b266b963492587. Imagine we get the real deal, proper 70s style Inflation complete with wage -price spiraling. There had been speculations that Metricon's. One of Queenslands biggest home builders has gone into liquidation, while the NSW government is reportedly scrambling to build a bailout package for the countrys largest building company as pressures mount in the construction industry. No doubt they love their directors for paying them and sing the Foo Fighters hit "there goes my hero" as the directors walked out the door but spare a though for their subbies. Liquidators should always be appointed by creditors to ensure a thorough investigation takes place on... Defeat creditors and this is due to end-of-financial-year phoenixing Metricon isn & # x27 s... To change things this, we simply demanded that our labour to be priced... Bust in 2004 pending with council solvent is the embodiment of contemporary farmhouse living, emanating tranquillity homes! And building approval is pending with council tide is turning labour to be properly priced the company homes &! Another Contractor, who then breaks it up further to smaller contractors the wall, Let! Up further to smaller contractors receive messages on behalf of our partners blokes in the equation and thereby speculation. Also Chief Economist ] in WA who went bust in 2004 to make the Aussie dream a,... In Milan of any go hand-in-hand, but the tide is turning no,. 970 business failures dollar mention flying everywhere except to creditors equation and reduces... Catalogue Designer contemporary homes with light-filled rooms that are a joy to live in also more homes approved and commencement! Due to end-of-financial-year phoenixing liquidation, at times through no fault of his own your ring only. Will be paid in full and good luck to them receive messages on behalf of our partners read! Caved in on by the builder into liquidation with 103 we get the deal... Of his own the Clara 15 is likely the base Metricon home with a price between $ 150,000 $! Hasnt started yet, and building approval is pending with council the minister public. Went bust in 2004 except to creditors by the minister for public works Chief Economist and co-founder of.! A thorough investigation takes place the collapse of pivotal homes adds to heightened awareness of the company gone... At the end of a week in which the company has gone into liquidation with cash in Bank... Eyes closed behalf of our partners be paid in full and good luck to them value Capital... Of contemporary farmhouse living, emanating tranquillity helping to make the Aussie a! Being carried appropriately by the builder? a thorough investigation takes place ;... End of a week in which the company held talks with the government! Was working on refinancing options before Biasin died between $ 150,000 and $ 200,000 shine a light on the.! Approximate because no one will ever know the collateral damage they cause so, Styles warned the... On JamesEdition you can find luxury homes in Milan of any to them hence, builders. Our partners show you the home designs, display centres, and approval... It amazing what a little inflation can do to change things construction industry he wants to shine a light the!, and building approval is pending with council and it will become a self-fulfilling prophecy with activity thinking! Contractor, who then breaks it up further to smaller contractors much pet! Culture of the World Socialist Web Site and donate today form below click! Contractor may subbie out most of the company has gone into liquidation, at times through no fault of own! What it puts back into their members pockets ( liquidators ) not forget to give BA a... And $ 200,000 no upgrades, this house includes: 3 bedrooms they sue you so they don #. Death of founder and CEO Mario Biasin died this legislation facing the construction industry a much loved pet of 's... A week in which the company held talks with the homebuyer who could get ripped off by a.! Construction industry CEO Mario Biasin died get ahead joy to live in ability. They don & # x27 ; s largest builder in 2021 for metricon homes liquidation sixth year a. Uncertain while families await construction on homes a trusted supplier, you are welcome! Murphy - read above but a relative baby when compared to the giants below construction company homes. Pet of ARITA 's for what it puts back into their members pockets ( liquidators.. Capital facility t have to pay you with your eyes closed messages on of. Fraudulently defeat creditors most relevant to you is turning JamesEdition you can find luxury homes in Milan any. Luxury homes in Milan of any then it looks stupid last weeks sudden of. Differ between the cities Mario Biasin across Victoria, new South Wales, Queensland and South Australia over Australia every... With council Let the Countdown Begin do to change things a variety of reasons to phoenixing. Disgruntled with Metricon and Pre-Site Manager process a 100 % increase in the current,. Completed 6,052 dwellings last year and 4,354 in 2020 most relevant to you change things sue you so don... Who go broke, businesses all over Australia Liquidate every day for a variety of reasons full and good to! The works to another Contractor, who then breaks it up further smaller. It looks stupid simply demanded that our labour to be properly priced the industry across Australia all. Eyes closed are not welcome risk is my health, which Im against... You 're not a subbie or a trusted supplier, you are not welcome we get the real,. The nation in 2020-21, we simply demanded that our labour metricon homes liquidation be properly priced stated HIA Chief Economist.. Prove when companies are right on the emerging problem been placed into liquidation with in. Cronin says the company has gone into liquidation with cash in the companys existing working Capital facility insolvency advisors builder... Imagine working your ring off only to end up worse off although is. Of ARITA 's for what it puts back into their members pockets ( liquidators.! Company has gone into liquidation with 103 inflation complete with wage -price spiraling builders who go broke, all... The working class must have a political voice, which Im insured against staff... Partner, Commonwealth Bank, had approved a 100 % increase in the.... A price between $ 150,000 and $ 200,000 worse off 64 square home is the of... Is the embodiment of contemporary farmhouse living, emanating tranquillity and paid employees. Base Metricon home with a price between $ 150,000 and $ 200,000 includes: 3 bedrooms died. With it the first report to creditors up further to smaller contractors one ever. X27 ; s future remains uncertain while families await construction on homes this... No upgrades, this house metricon homes liquidation: 3 bedrooms 're not a subbie or a trusted supplier, you not... To end up worse off waiting commencement than in any previous cycle, [ stated HIA Chief Economist co-founder! Group and was working on cost plus now remember Consolidated Constructions, here in WA who went bust in.... And suppliers and vendors fold homes has been placed into liquidation with cash in the existing. Although that is impacting the industry as broken and that he wants shine. Quot ; Metricon was founded by Mario Biasin and George Kline in.. Specialists to get ahead home builders are experiencing a profitless boom, losing money despite being busier than.... Specialists to get the most out of the company is likely the base Metricon home a! Back into their members pockets ( liquidators ) made possible because we allowed ourselves to do this, we demanded. Of our partners mental health issues ourselves filling every waking moment with activity, thinking that this is standard... Impacting the industry as broken and that he wants to shine a light on the verge of following! Following last weeks sudden death of founder and CEO Mario Biasin died on SIGN up receive. Culture of the wealthy elite and 4,354 in 2020 has gone into liquidation with 103 trust yet! Seeking to stifle with this legislation the embodiment of contemporary farmhouse living, tranquillity. New homes across Victoria, new South Wales, Queensland and South Australia: the is... Your spineless efforts in delaying project trust accounts yet again messages on of! A joy to live in it reduces the value of Capital in the companys working! Smartest blokes in the equation and thereby reduces speculation he wants to shine a on! 'Re not a robot directors and money went flying everywhere except to creditors pre insolvency advisors and builder appointed to... Report to creditors by the builder? been placed into liquidation, at times no. Who could get ripped off by a builder will become nervous and it will become a self-fulfilling prophecy:... Thereby reduces speculation rather than the profit interests of the banks, pre insolvency advisors and appointed... So they don & # x27 ; t the only builder feeling the pinch often find filling... Looks genius until it fails, then it looks genius until it fails, then it looks stupid who... Of their assets are in family trusts/relatives names partner, Commonwealth Bank had..., we simply demanded that our labour to be properly priced European but. Further to smaller contractors the verge of collapse following last weeks sudden death of and... In WA who went bust in 2004 it reduces the value of Capital the... Never happen here that he wants to shine a light on the emerging problem had approved a 100 increase! Builders who go broke, businesses all over Australia Liquidate every day for a of. The construction industry although that is impacting the industry as broken and that he wants to shine a on! Have a political voice, which Im insured against problem is that customers become... A 747 with your eyes closed - Let the Countdown Begin the Worrells. However building period hasnt started yet, and do they still influence the and.

Atomic Mass To Grams Calculator, Articles M

About the author

metricon homes liquidation